Independent reviews. When you buy through our links we may earn a commission — how we stay honest

Creamy chocolate and vanilla shakes with cookie-style toppings.

WheyWise recommended pick

NightCraft Slow Casein — Cookies & Cream

We recommend it for overnight recovery

Panel approved

Slow-release casein taken before bed feeds muscles overnight. This one thickens into a pudding-like texture, keeps you full, and the cookies and cream flavour earned our panel's highest night-time score. Take it 30 minutes before sleep.

Why we suggest it

  • Slow-release micellar casein
  • 24g protein for overnight recovery
  • Dessert-like pudding texture
  • Low sugar evening formula

Pros

  • slow release for overnight recovery
  • thick, dessert-like texture
  • low sugar

Cons

  • slow to mix and thick
  • not ideal straight after training
  • best used in the evening only

How we tested it: blind-tasted by our 12-person panel in water, milk and oats, with the label checked against independent lab data.

Get this pick

We suggest it — you decide. Check today's price and availability at the retailer.

Check Price at Retailer

Reader-supported: getting this product through our link may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. How we stay honest.

Compare it against the other four winners

Back to All Picks